Should You Remove Carrageenan from Your Diet?

Aug. 28, 2022 -

What is carrageenan?

Carrageenan is an additive used to thicken, emulsify, and preserve foods and drinks. It’s a natural ingredient that comes from red seaweed (also called Irish moss). You’ll often find this ingredient in nut milks, meat products, and yogurt.

Since the late 1960s, there’s been controversy surrounding the health effects of carrageenan. Some evidence suggests that carrageenan triggers inflammation, gastrointestinal ulcerations, and that it damages your digestive system. People have been petitioning for products with carrageenan to be labeled with a warning or removed entirely. Read on to learn more about this common food additive and why you may want to avoid it.

Dangers and side effects of carrageenan

Products with carrageenan may be labeled as “natural,” but limited studies show that carrageenan may promote or cause:

Increased inflammation can lead to a greater likelihood of other diseases, such as:

One reviewTrusted Source also suggests that there may be no substantial difference between “food-grade” (undegraded) and degraded carrageenan. Degraded carrageenan is a carcinogenic (cancer-causing) version that isn’t approved. It’s even used to induce inflammation in animal studies. According to Cornucopia, test results of food-grade carrageenan carried at least 5 percent degraded carrageenan. One sample had about 25 percent.

But many of the studies conducted on the dangers of carrageenan were on animals and cells. Reports of bloating, irritable bowel syndrome, and other digestive issues are mostly self-reported. People also report relief when they drop carrageenan from their diet. Healthline

Is Carrageenan Safe

An Image of Carrageenan Algae

Aug. 27, 2022 - DESCRIPTION: Carrageenan is a food additive used as a thickener and fat substitute in a variety of dairy and nondairy products. Concerns about potential intestinal tract damage are placed in the context of dietary consequences.

Carrageenan Warning! This “Healthy” Ingredient Causes Cancer, IBS and Gut Inflammation!

Aug. 27, 2022

Why Carrageenan in Food is Dangerous

Aug. 27, 2022 -

Trader’s Joes Branded Products and Carrageenan

Aug. 27, 2022 - This article will post later next week. Awaiting corporate office response.

Organic Dairy

Buttermilk with Carrageenan Buttermilk without Carrageenan
(Organic buttermilk producers that used to add carrageenan have reformulated their products to be carrageenan-free)
  • Butterworks Farm
  • Clover Stornetta
  • Hawthorne Valley
  • Kalona Supernatural
  • Natural By Nature
  • Organic Valley
Chocolate Milk With Carrageenan Chocolate Milk without Carrageenan
  • Castle Rock Organic Farms
  • Cow Wow Cereal Milk
  • Crystal Ball Farms
  • Equal Exchange Hot Chocolate (powdered)
  • Organic Valley (2% refrigerated)*
  • Strafford Organic Creamery
  • Thomas Organic Creamery
Cottage Cheese with Carrageenan Cottage Cheese without Carrageenan
  • Kalona Supernatural (regular and lowfat)
  • Nancy’s
  • Organic Valley (regular and lowfat)
Cream with Carrageenan Cream without Carrageenan
  • Butterworks Farm
  • Cedar Summit Farm
  • Clover Stornetta*
  • Horizon (half and half)*
  • Kalona Supernatural
  • Natural By Nature (heavy cream)*
  • Organic Valley (Pasteurized only, not Ultra Pasteurized)*
  • Strauss Family Creamery
  • Trickling Springs Creamery
Eggnog with Carrageenan Eggnog without Carrageenan
  • Kalona Supernatural
  • Strauss Family Creamery
  • Organic Valley
Ice Cream with Carrageenan Ice Cream without Carrageenan
  • Alden’s
  • Castle Rock Organic Farms
  • Crystal Ball Farms
  • Green and Black’s Organic
  • Julie’s
  • Mapleton’s Organic
  • Publix (note: Publix conventional ice cream does contain carrageenan)
  • Stonyfield
  • Strafford Organic Creamery
  • Strauss Family Creamery
  • Three Twins
Kefir with Carrageenan Kefir without Carrageenan
No organic kefir found with carrageenan – carrageenan is sometimes used in conventional kefir
  • Butterworks Farm
  • Cedar Summit (pourable yogurt)
  • Fresh Made
  • Helios
  • Lifeway
  • Nancy’s
  • Organic Pastures
  • Organic Valley (pourable yogurt)
Shelf-Stable Milk with Carrageenan (“milk boxes”) Shelf-Stable Milk without Carrageenan (“milk boxes”)
  • Horizon (lowfat)*
  • Organic Valley (regular, lowfat, strawberry flavored, vanilla)*
Sour Cream with Carrageenan Sour Cream without Carrageenan
  • 365 Whole Foods
  • Clover Stornetta
  • Horizon (regular only)*
  • Kalona Supernatural
  • Organic Valley (regular and lowfat)
  • Nancy’s
  • Strauss Family Creamery
  • Wallaby Organic
Yogurt with Carrageenan Yogurt without Carrageenan
  • Horizon (Tuberz™)*
  • Publix
  • Stonyfield (Oikos – caramel flavor only, Squeezers – all flavors)*
  • Trader Joe’s (Squishers™ and all but European-style plain whole milk, Greek-style yogurt, and vanilla organic yogurt cups in 6-pack)* Ingredients vary in Trader Joe’s products. Please read ingredients labels carefully.
  • Yami Organic
  • Butterworks
  • Cedar Summit (pourable)
  • Crystal Balls Farm
  • Hails Family Farm
  • Hawthorne Valley Farm
  • Horizon (all except Tuberz™)*
  • Kalona Supernatural
  • Maple Hill Creamery
  • Nancy’s
  • Organic Valley (pourable)
  • Redwood Hill Farms
  • Seven Stars
  • Stonyfield (all except caramel Oikos and Squeezers)*
  • Strauss Family Creamery
  • Thomas Organic Creamery
  • Trader Joe’s European-style plain whole milk, Greek-style yogurt, and vanilla organic yogurt cups* (Ingredients vary in Trader Joe’s products. Please read ingredients labels carefully.)
  • Wallaby Organic

Organic Dairy Alternative

Almond Milk with Carrageenan Almond Milk without Carrageenan
  • 365 Whole Foods
  • Beber
  • OMilk NYC
  • Trader Joe’s (refrigerated)* Ingredients vary in Trader Joe’s products. Please read ingredients labels carefully.
  • Wegman’s
  • Westsoy (the conventional line may contain carrageenan)
Cheese Alternative with Carrageenan Cheese Alternative without Carrageenan
  • Sunergia Soyfoods – SoyFeta and Soy Bleu Cheese
At this time, we are unable to find any organic cheese alternatives without carrageenan.
Chocolate Soymilk with Carrageenan Chocolate Soymilk without Carrageenan
  • Organic Valley
  • Tofu Shop
  • Soy Dream (enriched chocolate)
Coconut Milk with Carrageenan Coconut Milk without Carrageenan
  • So Delicious (organic vanilla, chocolate made with organic ingredients, and vanilla made with organic ingredients)*
  • Trader Joe’s (original, vanilla and light) Ingredients vary in Trader Joe’s products. Please read ingredients labels carefully.
  • Native Forest (canned milk or cream)
  • So Delicious (all organic culinary milk, latte and coconut beverages except those listed to the left) – reformulated in early 2014, check ingredients list*
  • Tropical Traditions (coconut cream concentrate)
Coconut Water with Carrageenan Coconut Water without Carrageenan
  • Coco Libre coconut water
  • Harmless Harvest Organic 100% Raw
  • Yoga Earth Purity (coconut water powder)
Coffee Creamer with Carrageenan Coffee Creamer without Carrageenan
  • Organic Valley
Flax Milk with Carrageenan Flax Milk without Carrageenan
At this time, we are unable to find any organic flax milk without carrageenan.
Frozen Dessert (non-dairy) with Carrageenan Frozen Dessert (non-dairy) without Carrageenan
  • So Delicious (coconut frozen desserts made with organic ingredients: German Chocolate, Cookie Dough (not GF) and all No Sugar Added products)*
  • 365 Whole Foods
  • Coconut Secret Raw Coconut Cream
  • Julie’s
  • Luna and Larry’s Coconut Bliss
  • Nadamoo
  • Natural Choice Fruit Bars
  • Organic Nectars
  • Sambazon
  • So Delicious (all frozen desserts and bars except those listed to the left)*
Oat Milk with Carrageenan Oat Milk without Carrageenan
No organic oat beverages found with carrageenan.
  • Pacific Foods (organic original, organic vanilla)
Rice Milk with Carrageenan Rice Milk without Carrageenan
  • B.R.A.T. (all flavors)
  • Kirkland Signature
  • Natur-a
  • Nature’s Promise (Giant)
  • Rice Dream – shelf-stable (organic classic original, organic enriched original)*
  • Trader Joe’s (Ingredients vary in Trader Joe’s products. Please read ingredients labels carefully.)
Soymilk with Carrageenan Soymilk without Carrageenan
  • Earth Balance* (Older formulations containing carrageenan remain on shelves. Watch ingredients!)
  • Eden Soy (EdenSoy contains no carrageenan except for chocolate-flavored EdenSoy. Eden is in the process of reformulating its chocolate soy milk.)
  • Natur-a
  • Organic Valley
  • Pacific Foods (organic unsweetened original)*
  • So Nice (Natural flavor only)*
  • Soy Dream (Shelf Stable: classic vanilla and enriched chocolate; Refrigerated: classic original)*
  • Sunrise Soya (all except light fortified sweetened)*
  • Tofu Shop
  • Trader Joe’s Unsweetened in aseptic package (refrigerated does contain carrageenan)* Ingredients vary in Trader Joe’s products. Please read ingredients labels carefully.
  • Twin Oaks
  • Vermont Soy* (unsweetened)
  • Westsoy (original, unsweetened, lowfat)*
Soynog with Carrageenan Soynog without Carrageenan
At this time, we are unable to find any organic soynog without carrageenan.
“Yogurt” (Non-Dairy) with Carrageenan “Yogurt” (Non-Dairy) without Carrageenan
  • So Delicious (coconut Greek yogurt flavors made with organic ingredients: chocolate, passionate mango, pina colada and strawberry banana)*
  • O’Soy (Stonyfield Organic soy yogurt)
  • So Delicious (unsweetened and unsweetened vanilla coconut yogurt made with organic ingredients and Greek coconut yogurt flavors made with organic ingredients: plain, blueberry, raspberry, strawberry and vanilla) – reformulated in early 2014, check ingredients list*
  • Trader Joe’s (soy yogurt) Ingredients vary in Trader Joe’s products. Please read ingredients labels carefully.
  • Whole Soy & Co. (soy yogurt)
  • Wildwood (soy yogurt)
  • Yoso (soy yogurt)

Organic Nutritional Drinks & Supplements

Nutritional Drinks with Carrageenan Nutritional Drinks without Carrageenan
  • Aloe Farms Aloe Vera Juice and Gel
  • Amazing Grass Kidz Superfood (removed carrageenan in 2015; read labels as old formulation may still be on shelves)
  • Aubrey Organics Pure Aloe Vera
  • B.R.A.T
  • Lily of the Desert Aloe Vera Juice*
  • NOW Aloe Vera Gel
  • Orgain (protein shakes, vegan nutritional shakes, meal powder and protein powder)
  • PediaSmart
  • Sambazon (Acai, Acai Berry + Yerba Mate + Guarana, Supergreens Kale + Ginger, Blended Breakfast, Amazon Energy)*
  • Svelte organic protein shakes

Organic Deli Meat

Deli Meat with Carrageenan Deli Meat without Carrageenan
  • Applegate (Packaged and Sliced: Roasted Chicken, Turkey Breast, Roasted Turkey Breast, Smoked Chicken, Smoked Turkey Breast)*
  • Applegate (Roast Beef, Genoa Salami, Uncured Ham)*
  • Organic Prairie

Organic Dips

Dips with Carrageenan Dips without Carrageenan
  • Marzetti’s Organic Ranch Veggie Dip
  • Simply Organic Dip Mixes

Organic Juice

Juice with Carrageenan Juice without Carrageenan
  • Lakewood (Acai Amazon Berry and Coconut)*
  • Apple and Eve
  • Columbia Gorge
  • Honest Kids
  • Knudsen’s (all flavors except Yumberry)
  • Lakewood (all flavors except Acai Amazon Berry and Coconut)*
  • Organic Valley
  • Publix
  • Santa Cruz
  • Uncle Matt’s

Organic Prepared Foods

Desserts/Snacks with Carrageenan Desserts/Snacks without Carrageenan
  • There are many without carrageenan. Please watch the ingredients labels.
Pizza with Carrageenan Pizza without Carrageenan
  • Bold Organics Dairy-Free Pizza
  • Annie’s Organic Frozen Pizza (Annie’s has removed carrageenan from its pizza, but please read labels until the older product is off the market)
  • 365 Whole Foods
  • Amy’s (70% organic)
  • Annie’s Organic Frozen Pizza (Annie’s has removed carrageenan from its pizza, but please read labels until the older product is off the market)
  • Nature’s Promise
  • Publix
  • Rising Moon Organics (70% organic)
  • Trader Joe’s (Ingredients vary in Trader Joe’s products. Please read ingredients labels carefully.)
Prepared Meals with Carrageenan Prepared Meals without Carrageenan
  • Amy’s Baked Ziti Bowl, Kids Baked Ziti Bowl, Vegetable Lasagna
  • There are many prepared meals without carrageenan. Please watch the ingredients labels.